Ethics and few good men

The victim, PFC Santiago, died after the two defendants tied him up and gagged him. Aristotle would be on stronger grounds if he could show that in the absence of close friends one would be severely restricted in the kinds of virtuous activities one could undertake.

We regard those that are beautiful and rare as valuable, and those that are ugly as foul and rotten The foul and rotten may come to be transformed into what is rare and valuable, and the rare and valuable into what is foul and rotten.

A Few Good Men

If one lived in a community filled with good people, and cooperated on an occasional basis with each of them, in a spirit of good will and admiration, would that not provide sufficient scope for virtuous activity and a well-lived life? Although the movie is a comedy, the lessons are real: These terms play an evaluative role, and are not simply descriptions of someone's state of mind.

Being skilled in an art can also be described as a mean between excess and deficiency: The only underived reason for action is self-interest; that an act helps another does not by itself provide a reason for performing it, unless some connection can be made between the good of that other and one's own.

A Few Good Men: Top 5 Attorney Ethics Traps

Perhaps the most telling indication of this ordering is that in several instances the Ethics and few good men Ethics develops a theme about which its Eudemian cousin is silent. It is not without reason, then, that we do not call an ox, or a horse, or any brute happy; for none of them is able to share in this kind of activity.

A person who is not virtuous will often find his or her perceptions of what is most pleasant to be misleading.

Jean-Jacques Rousseau (1712—1778)

Jessup is remarkably childish for a full bird colonel in the United States Marine Corps. Since—to resume—all knowledge and all purpose aims at some good, what is this which we say is the aim of Politics; or, in other words, what is the highest of all realizable goods? These are precisely the questions that were asked in antiquity by the Stoics, and they came to the conclusion that such common emotions as anger and fear are always inappropriate.

Obligations that were enforced would, by the virtue of the force behind them, not be freely undertaken and would not be in the realm of the ethical. This is another example of Hollywood Lawin real life, rejecting a plea bargain without consulting the client would get an attorney disbarred.

Later, at the invitation of her husband, St. He has been claimed as a founder of cognitive science. Suppose we grant, at least for the sake of argument, that doing anything well, including living well, consists in exercising certain skills; and let us call these skills, whatever they turn out to be, virtues.

Pleasure is good, and the pleasure that consists in the highest activity is the good. Lieutenant Kendrick claims being Christian in his testimony, but simultaneously exposes his absolute absence of compassion.

Chapter 6: A Few Good Men?

This public rejection, combined with rifts in his personal relationships, left him feeling betrayed and even as though he was the victim of a great conspiracy. On the contrary, his defense of self-love makes it clear that he is not willing to defend the bare idea that one ought to love oneself alone or above others; he defends self-love only when this emotion is tied to the correct theory of where one's good lies, for it is only in this way that he can show that self-love need not be a destructive passion.

Kendrick says Santiago is dead because "he had no code, he had no honor, and God was watching. Jessup is the base commander at Guantanamo Bay, a fairly important posting note that the movie predates the War on Terror which at least de facto borders enemy territory, and has a large contingent of Marines under his command.


His father got into a quarrel with a French captain, and at the risk of imprisonment, left Geneva for the rest of his life. The famous climactic scene between Kaffee and Jessup.

Aristotle might be taken to reply: But surely it is strange that when he is happy we should refuse to say what is true of him, because we do not like to apply the term to living men in view Edition: Aristotle points to the fact that many aims are really only intermediate aims, and are desired only because they make the achievement of higher aims possible.

Undemonstrated facts always form the first step or starting-point of Peters The pleasure of recovering from an illness, for example, is bad without qualification—meaning that it is not one of the pleasures one would ideally choose, if one could completely control one's circumstances. We should take note of a further difference between these two discussions: Rather, when he says that unequal relationships based on character are imperfect, his point is that people are friends in the fullest sense when they gladly spend their days together in shared activities, and this close and constant interaction is less available to those who are not equal in their moral development.

Many of the Marines suffer from this, believing that they are above reproach because of the nature of their work and their ultimately good intentions. In Book II of the Republic, we are told that the best type of good is one that is desirable both in itself and for the sake of its results da.

No one had written ethical treatises before Aristotle.

A Scrutiny of the Ethical Dilemmas in ‘A Few Good Men’

These views are continually discussed among both feminist and Rousseau scholars. And if it is what a man does that determines the character of his life, as we said, then no happy man will become miserable; for he will never do what is hateful and base.

Shareholder value thinking was always about creating wealth. Opening pages of 'Age of Reason' Thus passes away all man's life. Being of "great soul" magnanimitythe virtue where someone would be truly deserving of the highest praise and have a correct attitude towards the honor this may involve.

Indeed, from the very beginning Jo looks down on Kaffee because he resolves all of his cases with plea bargains, while she is so opposed to plea bargaining that as a trial lawyer, she only resolved three cases in two years.

He describes a sequence of necessary steps to achieve this:I answered an almost identical question on this before (but not enough to merge the two): my answer to What do members of the U.S. Marine Corps think of the movie A Few Good Men? A Few Good Men can be summed up for U.S. Marine Corps in the courtro.

Corporate Governance and Ethics is an illuminating and practical reading of Aristotle’s Politics for today’s corporate directors. With a deft synthesis of ethics, economics and politics, Alejo Sison elevates the discussion of corporate governance out of the realm of abstract rules and structures.

the lawyer defending the two marines in A Few Good Men has to consider whether he should go beyond the legal and ethical codes under which he is bound and accuse a witness on the stand of committing a crime for which the two marines are accused.

Check out our top Free Essays on Ethical Dilemmas In The Movie A Few Good Men to help you write your own Essay. The Nicomachean Ethics (/ ˌ n ɪ k oʊ ˈ m æ k i ə n /; Ancient Greek: Ἠθικὰ Νικομάχεια) is the name normally given to Aristotle's best-known work on work, which plays a pre-eminent role in defining Aristotelian ethics, consists of ten books, originally separate scrolls, and is understood to be based on notes from his lectures at the Lyceum.

So, what have we learned from A Few Good Men? And that when it comes to honor, Isn't consistent obedience necessary for the success of the whole military endeavor?

Ethics and few good men
Rated 4/5 based on 8 review